I've always been fascinated with miniatures - not only military ones. When I was about 10 years old, I had a model train table with a simple track layout, model houses and trees (some of which are still being used on my wargaming table), and later on ventured into model building (mostly planes), before properly settling down on toy soldiers and wargames.
Recently, I cleaned out some old closets in the elderly house (my mom never throws anything out, so there are still toys to find from 30+ years ago), and found a box of plastic miniature animals. These are the cheap kind, 1 euro for a bag of multi-scaled, badly painted, barely recognizable animals. However, I did re-use them before, because some of them were missing heads and legs, which now appear on some of my chaos beastman units -- careful converted models when I was a GW-junkie.
Anyway, always looking for weird and unusual games, I was wondering whether miniature animals could be used in a proper miniature game. I'm not talking about putting the occasional pig, goat or horse on the battlefield as a scenery element, but a game about the animals themselves.
Several things are spiking my curiousity: There are of course plenty of cheap toy animals available, making a game with zillions of miniatures possible. But also, there are some very high quality ranges (e.g. Schleich), various 25mm manufacturers make animals as well, there are collectors (e.g. The Zooman), and even flats (e.g. at Berliner Zinnfiguren). And I'm a big fan of Zoo Tycoon, an excellent computer game about managing your own zoo.
So, the question is not, whether an interesting game can be built around miniature toy animals in a zoo (I already have some cunning ideas ;-)), but whether this would still be considered part of the hobby we love?
After all, it would still be miniature gaming, although not wargaming. But is playing with miniatures not the main thing in our hobby? And does it matter whether these miniatures are soldiers, animals or matchbox cars?
This touches upon something I've been wanting to write about as well (and have referred to passingly before): the taxonomy of miniature wargamers. If you take the term _historical miniature wargaming_ (or fantasy or SF for that matter), there are really three different things involved here:
ReplyDelete* __historical__ miniature __war__gaming: we study / recreate / make ludicrously uninformed comments about military history
* historical __miniature__ wargaming: we do this through playing with toy soldiers, or tiny tin men
* historical miniature war__gaming__: we do this to play games, which can be further subdivided in playing games in, competitions or just socially
Each of us probably assigns different importances to these factors. For me, the miniatures part is the most important among these two (the painting and modelling of figures and terrain), with the other two following close behind (probably in the order gaming before history).
What you are proposing here is something with a very strong emphasis on gaming and miniatures, but less on history. Nothing wrong with that, I think. It's all the same hobby: we play games with toy soldiers.
Many years ago I asked a question on several wargaming related newsgroups (that dates it..) about whether playing wargames with counters in place of miniatures was still the same hobby.
ReplyDeleteThe resulting debate was heated.
I'm happy playing games with counters. I'm happy collecting and painting miniatures that I'll never use in games. I'm happy reading about periods I'll never play nor collect.
Games like Blood Bowl, Pig Tickler and Futbowel take miniature games away from the battlefield and onto the sports field. At the end of the day aren't Subbuteo and Scalextrix miniature games?
Phil,
ReplyDeleteHow about a game based on "animal farm"? Should be fun...
Rudi
As I have ethical issues with zoos and farm animals, I'd want to play the animals breaking out or taking over the farm.
ReplyDeleteAnd in answer to you question, well you might have difficulties in publishing an article in a serious wargames magazine, but who cares what you call it?
You have copy of H G Wells's 'Floor games' (or rather you have an original and I have a copy). I suppose your idea resembles a version of that for 21st century madmen.
Alan,
ReplyDeleteHmmm, I didn't realize people might find a game set in a zoo offensive in some way. You're probably right, it probably is upsetting to animal lovers.
I still like Zoo Tycoon though! :-)
Phil
Don't worry, Phil. I could hardly claim 'ethical objections' to playing a zoo game when I'm quite willing to command Panzers, Confederates or the British in India!
ReplyDelete