We used our hexified version of the game (as discussed here), but we adapted some more things: units could be in adjacent hexes (one unit = one hex, so no confusion possible), and we used dials to track strength points. We didn't use the idea of group orders, as discussed in this blogpost.
Moreover, since I found the original troop rosters too unwieldy, I quickly made some troop cards for easy reference during the game (and as could be expected, there were some wrong statistics on them due to copy-paste mistakes). The biggest change in statistics lines was to simply list modifiers for activation rolls, relative to a baseline of 6+. So all troops activate on a 6+ for all actions, but some have a +1 (activate on 5+) or a -1 (activate on 7+). I think this provides a better perception on the advantages and disadvantages of each troop type.
I also made some cards to draw a random leader characteristic, and to draw some random spells for each wizard. I think that assigning 3 random spells to each wizard provides more fun and thinking, rather than allowing each wizard to use all possible spells - which would quickly degenerate in throwing fireballs back and forth.
|Chaos Army cards|
|Elven army cards|
|Random Leader trait|
- When using large numbers of units, the activation system starts to break down. So group activation would be a nice thing to have.
- The differences in activation rolls barely influence player's decisions. So either we should change all activation rolls to 6+, or provide +2 or -2 modifiers to change this characteristic into something that actually does influence the decisions made by players. Personally, I am not a big fan of varying troop characteristics simply to add flabour - they should also have meaning and influence decisions in gameplay.
- The combat resolution system is a bit tedious. Rolling 12 dice for each combat, counting hits, then dividing by Armour value ... both players said it takes the "punch" out of rolling the dice. You should be able to see at a glance how much damage you did. The Armour mechanic makes this difficult.
- Battered units with a -5, -6 modifier have it difficult to recover, but they still are not routing. They keep "hanging around" untill at last they Courage rollf alls below 0. When units are written off - for all practical considerations - they should get removed more quickly.
|Bart and Koen pondering their strategy|
|Reinforcements waiting on the sidelines.|
|Elven army rushing towards the statues. Marauder Giant (nicknamed Freddy) leading from the front.|
|Chaos army deploying|
|Elven spearmen taking the first statue.|
|Freddy occupying another statue.|
|More Elven spearmen|
|A Tree horror and some Minotaurs running over the hills.|
|Gygax the Dragon fighting the Chaotic Evil forces.|
|The battle in full swing.|
|And yet another view. Since my wargaming room is not that big a room, it is difficult to get good wide perspective shots.|
|A look from the Chaos battle lines.|
|Giant Spider with Venomous attacks.|
|And yet another overview.|
|And another random picture.|